Hanky Panky? There’s No Hanky Panky In Tai Chi!
Let me begin by saying, that emphatic statement is not entirely true. Before I tell you why it’s not really true I’d like to explain what I’m getting at. Later I’ll let you in on what got me thinking about this.
When playing tai chi the movement of the shoulders through space has little or nothing to do with the shoulders. When beginners watch their teachers and then mimic a move they invariably twist their bodies to get their shoulders into what they believe is the proper position. The movement of the hands and shoulders is distracting them and what’s missed, almost without exception, is the turning of the waist.
The upper body is strongest when the shoulders and hips are in alignment with one another. When movement is controlled by through the waist, there is power. When there is proper, alignment, and only as much tension as necessary to maintain alignment, there is movement of energy. When there is controlled movement of energy, there is increased power.
Practice keeping your shoulders over your hips and use your hips to turn your shoulders. Your tai chi will improve dramatically.
When I said that there really is hanky panky in tai chi, what I was referring to are the hidden movements designed to surprise opponents, and occasional misdirection through extending one hand to distract the opponent while striking with the other. There is also the use of the efu, or uniform, to hide the subtleties of movement from the opponenent as well as bystanders. So yes, there is hanky panky in tai chi, just as in other martial arts.
Now, the not-so-little-known fact that got me thinking about this comes from the practice of magic. Specifically sleight of hand. I found this reference in the book Who Knew?, by David Hoffman.
The term “Hanky Panky” stems from the magician’s practice of using a handkerchief in one hand to distract the audience from noticing what he is doing with the other.
Your thoughts?
John
Click on "Express yourself" below to leave your comment. (Comments are great!)
The “Sphere: Related Content” button looks for similar stories on the internet. “Tell a Friend” lets you bookmark this post or email it to a friend without having to leave the page. “Share and Enjoy” let’s you bookmark this post on lots of different sites or even print it out. I want you to tell others about this site so share away… please!
Express yourself, click here to leave a comment (4 comments, add yours)
Be notified of new comments for this post via RSS
4 People have left comments on this post
May 28, 2009 - 06:05:11I do wonder how much of the form we’ve learnt was all an artifice to conceal knowledge from curious onlookers.
Certainly there are so many subtleties that if you blinked you’d miss them!
tannage from Taijipedia’s last blog post..Relaxation Part 1 – The Relaxation Trigger Habit and Infinite Onions.
Tannage,
Oh yeah, I forgot that part. There’s no blinking in tai chi either.
John
My Master has been heard to say ” no waist is not tai chi”
I am trying to experience/learn/practice this thru Brush Knee. I am waiting for more insight before I attempt to engage with the apparent simplicity of Cloud Hands - very uncloudy just yet - more clunky.
Too much waisted effort.
Minh,
I like the pun on “waisted” effort. A training brother of mine, who lives in Beijing, spent 2 weeks of practice time doing nothing but cloud hands back and forth across a large field so he could begin to “grasp it”.
Good luck,
John